2012 IDP Waiver Wire Pickups: Week 5

Hello and welcome back to the IDPGuru.com's most popular in-season article, IDP Waiver Wire Pickups, which will be releasing every Tuesday of the regular season.

Let's start things off by going through some IDP news, notes, and commentary from Week 4 of the NFL season.

CB William Gay was benched last week in favor of CB Greg Toler. This is a situation to monitor closely as it was just two seasons ago when Toler put up 82 solos. Could end up being a very sneaky pickup.

Eagles waived LB Brian Rolle. Look for Jamar Chaney and/or Akeem Jordan to assume the WLB duties. Not much fantasy value here at all.

Troy Polamalu
looks like he will play this week. Solid DB2.

Redskins SS Brandon Meriweather will be out "at least a week" with a left MCL/PCL injury. Reed Doughty started in Meriweather's place following his pre-game collision Sunday.

Giants SS Kenny Phillips has been diagnosed with a sprained right MCL, and is week-to-week.

Will Witherspoon rotated heavily with Zac Diles at linebacker last week. Colin McCarthy looks like he will be back this week, but Witherspoon should be dumped either way.

Studs such as Jared Allen, Cameron Wake, Charles Johnson, and George Wilson all had very nice weeks and are back on the path to IDP stardom.

Bobby Wagner had a nice game, but he still isn't playing in subpackages. Until he does, I would avoid him as anything other than a LB4+.

With the Jets losing Santonio Holmes for the year with a foot fracture, they could very well end up being the worst offense in the league. This could mean a big spike in tackle opportunity for LB David Harris. He's been outstanding the last couple of weeks and has a top tier tackle matchup this week against Houston. He has LB1 potential ROS. I would also upgrade LaRon Landry and Yeremiah Bell as well.

Now onto The Guru's IDP waiver wire selections for Week 5!

(Please note that a majority of these pickups are long-term, rest of season pickups as opposed to matchup-type recommendations. As the season progresses and the waiver wire becomes more thin and matchup information becomes more reliable, the focus of this article will shift more towards recommendations based on weekly matchup.)

Defensive Linemen

(Previously recommended DLs: Chandler Jones, Derrick Morgan, Derrick Wolfe, Greg Hardy, Randy Starks, Darnell Dockett, Cameron Jordan, Henry Melton, Tyson Alualu, Carlos Dunlap, Michael Bennett, Michael Johnson, Tyson Alualu)

RDE Cameron Wake (MIA) - I've been preaching patience with Wake the last couple of weeks. Leading up to last week, he led the league in QB hurries/hits, however had no sacks to show for it. That changed last week when he destroyed the Arizona Cardinals with 4.5 sacks. He's a DL1 moving forward and should be owned in all formats. If someone was dumb/impatient enough to drop him, scoop him up now!

RDE John Abraham (ATL) -
Abraham leads all current NFL players in sacks. However, Father Time is starting to catch up to the 13 year veteran and he doesn't receive nearly the amount of snaps he use to in his younger days. His limited snap count is keeping him more fresh however and he has 3 sacks so far this season. He has a nice matchup against the Redskins this week and is a top 10 DL play in balanced and sack-heavy scoring formats. 

DT Henry Melton (CHI) - Melton has consistently been beating interior linemen off the ball and last week against Dallas was no exception. He's had a sack in 3 of the first 4 weeks and I expect that trend to continue this week against the Jacksonville Jaguars. He's a solid DL3 option.

LDE Everson Griffen (MIN) -
Griffin doesn't receive enough playing time to be counted on as anything more than a long shot DL3, deep league DL4 type player at this point. But he has had 3 sacks so far this season and with Jared Allen gaining more effectiveness, Griffin should see more one-on-one matchup opportunities in the interior. Not a superb play, but you could do worse this week.


(Previously recommended LBs: Wesley Woodyard, Larry Foote, Jerrell Freeman, Paris Lenon, Erin Henderson, Russell Allen, Dannell Ellerbe, Akeem Ayers, Will Witherspoon, Zach Brown, Phillip Wheeler, Rey Maualuga)

WLB Vontaze Burfict (CIN) - Ever since Thomas Howard went on IR after Week 1, I've been keeping a close eye on the Cincinnati WLB position. I think Burfict is the real deal and has a chance to be the best fantasy linebacker on the team come year's end. He's an instinctive player who has a knack for being around the ball. The coaches like him and most importantly, he has little competition for tackles. He's worth a LB4 roster spot in 10 and 12 team leagues.

WILB Pat Angerer (IND) - Angerer looks like he will make his season debut this week against the Green Bay Packers. There's no reason why he shouldn't be on your roster if he is still sitting on the waiver wire (unless you are already stacked at LB). He was a stud last year and will be a stud this year as long as he's healthy.

MLB Colin McCarthy (TEN) -
This is an obvious one. Coaches said McCarthy looked great in practice and he is looking like a good bet to start against the Vikings this week. If by some chance, he's still on your waiver wire, pick him up. LB1 with top 5 potential.

LOLB James Harrison (PIT) -
Similar to Angerer, Harrison will likely see his first game action of the season this week. He goes up against Michael Vick and the Eagles. Although he's suffered some significant injuries over the last couple of seasons, Harrison is as tough as they come and has shown that he can play quite effectively even when not at 100%. He's a guy that I always like to take a chance on if I need big production out of my LB3/4 spot and am willing to get a bit risky.

SILB Demorrio Williams (SD) -
This is going to be a one week waiver wire pickup suggestion. Williams is not a starer. However, he plays in all of San Diego's nickel packages and with the Saints on the schedule this week, he will figure to see 80-85% of the snaps. Historically, he's produced when he's played. If you are looking for a LB4 in super deep leagues to start this week, Williams is a nice option.

Defensive Backs

(Previously recommended DBs: T.J. Ward, Craig Dahl, William Moore, Alterraun Verner, Tracy Porter, Michael Griffin, Madieu Williams, Buster Skrine, William Gay, Josh Norman, Atari Bigby, Jordan Babineaux, John Wendling)

SS Jordan Babineaux (TEN) - Babineaux has been on this list before, so I won't expel too much about him. In short, he's a mediocre player in a great situation. The Titans are receiving a ton of tackle opportunity and will likely continue to receive a ton as the season wears on. He's a solid DB2+, especially in tackle-heavy leagues.

FS Matt Giordano (OAK) - Due to the injuries at the CB position, the Raiders have temporarily moved Michael Huff from free safety to cornerback. Giordano has taken his place at safety and his put up good numbers during that time. We've seen similar production from Giordano in short starter stints last season. He should be counted on for 5-7 solos per game.

FS Rahim Moore (DEN) - Moore, a 2nd round pick out of UCLA last season, has started to emerge as one of the better young players on the Broncos roster. He's still 22 years old and still suffers from consistency problems, but his upside is high enough in certain matchups to use him as a bye week/injury DB3 filler. He has the Chargers and Patriots in his next two matchups and has a good chance of exceeding expectations in those weeks and perhaps beyond.

FS Malcolm Jenkins (NO) -
For most of his career, Jenkins has failed to make a big splash in the tackle column on an extended basis. However, the Saints' defense has been on the field for larger spans of time this season which has led to an increased amount of tackle opportunity. Add in a weaker front seven and you have a recipe for a significant increase in tackle production. So far through four games, Jenkins has registered 33 total tackles. He has a very good matchup this week against the Chargers and should be started with confidence.

If you have any questions, feel free to email me at theidpguru@idpguru.com or follow me on Twitter. Also, feel free to post any questions or comments for me in the comments section of this post.

Last Updated: October 3, 2012
Related Posts:


Aaron Clark said...

Jerrell Freeman
Dawan Landry
Sean Weatherspoon
Nick Barnett

PerrY Riley
Craig Dahl

I know I should be starting McCarthy, but do I put him in? If I do put him in, who do I bench to place him in? HELP ME!! I'm 0-4. I've never started out like this before with all the studs I have on offense and defense.

Ryan Sitzmann said...

@Aaron Clark
I will bench Freeman and start McCarthy.

Ewok Juggernaut said...

Hey Ryan, big fan here!

I've got Sean Lee on a BYE and was going to start Jerrell Freeman this week but now after reading about Pat Angerer's return does Freeman go back to the bench? Here is a list of my LB's who would you start (I need 2)? And is Freeman still an every down Linebacker with Angerer coming back?

Patrick Willis
Jerrell Freeman
KJ Wright
James Anderson
Kelvin Sheppard
Sean Lee (BYE)

Ryan Sitzmann said...

@Ewok Juggernaut
I think Freeman goes back to the bench and no longer is an every down linebacker.

I'd start Willis and James Anderson.

Aiah said...

Hello Ryan,

I'm in a ten team league with 16 players. I have Akeem Ayers but Nick Barnett and Pat Angerer just became available. Should I keep Ayers or take one of the other two. Thanks.

Ryan Sitzmann said...

I'd drop Ayers and pickup Angerer. Barnett may be slightly better this week, but I like Angerer ROS.

Mr Neil el Jefe said...

Hey Guru any thoughts on Erin Henderson? He was a stud prior to concussion and now they say Brinkley is gonna replace him in Nickel packages, Thoughts? Thinking of rolling Vontaze over him due to that this week

Nate said...

Hey Guru, quick one for you.

Verner or Bell this week and ROS?

Tackle heavy format. Thanks.

jeramiehieb said...

Can't give you enough praise... YOU'RE DOING GREAT WORK HERE.

I know this question is similar to a few above, but it is different...anyways.

I start 3LB (Tackle=1pt, Asst=1/2 pt)

Start: Ray Lewis, DQwell Jackson, Colin McCarthy

Bench: Akeem Ayers, Jerrell Freeman

Question: Pat Angerer is available on the wire. From what I have read above you would agree to pick up Pat, but which is the better back up to keep, Ayers or Freeman?

Ryan Sitzmann said...

@Mr Neil el Jefe
He's likely to rotate this week. I'd go with Burfict this week over Henderson.

Ryan Sitzmann said...

I like Bell more this week, but Verner more ROS.

scott said...

Hey Ryan,

For week 5, Bell, Pollard, Bigby or Moore at S. I have Bigby but the others are all available in tackle heavy league.

Ryan Sitzmann said...

I like William Moore this week.

bob smith said...

T. Polamalu vs Phi or K. Coleman vs Pit for T. Branch on a bye. Should I drop Branch for one of them or just hold him on the bench for a week.
1 Pt Tackle
. 5 ass. Tackle
5 sack
5 int
3 off
3 fr
6 defensive TD
6 safety
3 pass def
5 block kick

leenypost said...

Ryan, would you drop Rolondo McClain for Vontaze Burfict going forward?

Ryan Sitzmann said...

I like McClain slightly better (especially since he's byed out).

Post a Comment

Leave a comment, question, or derogatory remark!

***NOTE: Please use a different display name than "Anonymous" when asking advice questions. It gets difficult to discern who I am answering when multiple people post under the same name.

Also, when asking for weekly matchup advice please mention the weekly opponent for each player you are listing. This helps me answer questions more quickly.
In addition, always list your scoring system as my advice will differ depending on the type of system being used.

Lastly, please don't duplicate the same exact post on other pages. We get notified of all comments that are posted and we will make sure to answer questions as quickly as we can. Posting the same question multiple times on different pages just slows the whole process down for everyone.