IDP Showdown: Calais Campbell vs. Mathias Kiwanuka

I thought it would be fun to start a series entitled "IDP Showdown" in which I compare two IDPs who have very similar ADPs. Each player will be judged on five different categories: Tackles, Sacks, Opportunity, Health, and Safeness of the Pick.

For simplicity's sake, when analyzing these players only 2010 production will be taken into account. In other words, I am only judging their redraft value.

Calais Campbell
LDE Calais Campbell

Arizona Cardinals

Current ADP: 247.09
Min Pick: 106
Max Pick: 405
Mathias Kiwanuka
RDE Mathias Kiwanuka
New York Giants

Current ADP: 249.07
Min Pick: 129
Max Pick: 542

Tackles: Kiwanuka is a very strong tackler for his position. He had 60 total tackles last season as a rotational pass rusher. The Giants have been experimenting with him at strong side linebacker and I expect very healthy tackle numbers. I don't see Campbell outproducing him in this category.

Sacks: This is a close call. In Kiwanuka's only full season, he put up 8.5 sacks. I forsee similar numbers this season. Campbell had 6.5 sacks last year and given his upward trajectory, I could see around 8 sacks. I will call this one a draw.

Opportunity: I give the slight edge to Kiwanuka on this one because he plays RDE on a 4-3 defense whereas Campbell is a LDE on a 3-4. They both will rotate about the same amount. However, I believe the Giants are going to put Kiwanuka at linebacker for a few snaps each game giving him the advantage in this category.

Health: Both players have been healthy throughout their careers and aren't considered injury risks at this point in time.

Safeness: Both of these players are fairly safe picks at a position that is lacking in fantasy depth.

WINNER: I give Kiwanuka my vote. He's just as safe of a selection as Campbell, but he has higher upside. He's the starting RDE and will also probably see some snaps at SLB. He's on perhaps the most talented defensive line in the league and should see plenty of one-on-one matchups.

So who do you think wins this battle?? Any suggestions for future battles? Please leave your comments below. I'm really interested on any input you may have or any ideas for future showdown articles.

Bookmark and Share

Related Posts:


Anonymous said...

Kiwanuka for sure...and that's why he's on my team :)

Post a Comment

Leave a comment, question, or derogatory remark!

***NOTE: Please use a different display name than "Anonymous" when asking advice questions. It gets difficult to discern who I am answering when multiple people post under the same name.

Also, when asking for weekly matchup advice please mention the weekly opponent for each player you are listing. This helps me answer questions more quickly.
In addition, always list your scoring system as my advice will differ depending on the type of system being used.

Lastly, please don't duplicate the same exact post on other pages. We get notified of all comments that are posted and we will make sure to answer questions as quickly as we can. Posting the same question multiple times on different pages just slows the whole process down for everyone.